This simple comic book grading guide is draft to help you market comic publications you have found, bought, or inherited.

You are watching: How to rate comic book condition

It"s not supposed to be an skilled guide come grading comic books. In fact, I"m far from an expert.

But i CAN teach friend to easily assess around what your comic publication grades at, and also therefore, around what your comic publication is worth.

That is every the ability you will need to determine the median grade of your comic books. When you have actually that information, it will certainly be a lot less complicated to get them appraised.

The Mint condition Myth

The most common problem through comic publication grading is, it"s subjective.

Most world see a comic native the 1980s in a plastic bag and also presume that it"s "mint condition". You watch this every the time:

"Collection the vintage comics, tho in initial bags, mostly 1980s and 1990s, mint condition!"

There space several difficulties with that description.

Almost NO comics came in bagsThe comics may have been placed in bags critical week after 25 years stuffed in a box.You need the ideal kind that bags, and acid-free backing boards.Most civilization see "little faults" (like creases across the corner) and presume they space unimportant.

Truly mint problem comics, also from as recently as the 1980s, are an extremely hard come come by.

This is extremely necessary if you"re to buy comics. It"s less important if all you desire to perform is market some comics you"ve found, or inherited.

Comic book Grades Explained

Comic book grading is based on a score the end of 10:

0-1.5 = negative to great minus2.0-3.5 = same to very good minus4.0-5.5 = very an excellent to well minus6.0-7.5 = fine to an extremely fine minus8.0 = very fine8.5 = an extremely fine plus9.0 = an extremely fine/near mint9.2 = near mint minus9.4 = near mint9.6 = near mint plus9.8 = close to mint to mint9.9 = mint10.0 = gem mint

Let"s display you some examples, therefore you deserve to understand what YOUR books grade ~ above this scale.

What a fair (1.0 Graded) Comic publication Looks Like


Worn, torn, stained, ice repaired, composed on, cover loose, rusted staples, hefty creasing... These are all faults you will find on the worst condition comics.

NOTE: if a comic is incomplete for any reason (missing pages, coupons clipped, sheathe gone), the is virtually worthless.

What a good (2.0 Graded) Comic publication Looks Like


It"s still a quite rough-looking specimen, but a good comic need to at least be solid, readable, and fairly presentable.

Most that the faults discovered on bad comic publications can apply. There have to be a few less the them.

What a Very great (4.0 Graded) Comic publication Looks Like


Very good comics quiet look well-read, however they"re starting to seem less of a deteriorate for collectors who don"t simply want to read their books.

This is the worst grade once it"s agree to check out tape repairs.

You have to look in ~ a very good comic and also not feel embarrassed if a friend observed it in your collection.

What a well (6.0 Graded) Comic publication Looks Like


For most "serious" collectors, good is the shortest acceptable grade.

While there have the right to be wear, some minor creasing and other faults, a fine comic book usually has actually most of its covering gloss, and looks pretty quite at an initial glance.

It"s much more the amount of small faults (or one significant one) the brings this book down native a greater grade.


Why This overview is AWESOME because that Wannabe Comic Investors

If you have actually either tried (and failed) to do money flipping comic books, or space frustrated by the huge array of choice out there, then this is the eBook for you.

It"s packed v 32 thorough analyses of easy-to-buy and sell comic publications from the bronze to modern-day ages.

These space titles we have actually personally made a most money buying and also selling. So have the right to you.

Make much more than her money ago with your very first successful trade (or by no buying a shedding book!).

If you room not fully satisfied, we have actually a 365-day money-back guarantee.

Click to review more, or order your copy today!

What a really Fine (8.0 Graded) Comic book Looks Like

Now we"re getting into the are where the worth of her comic publications spikes up rapidly. The price difference in between the worth of a fine and also a very fine comic publication can be dual or more.

Generally a really fine comic either is a close to mint, v one nasty error bringing it down, or a close to mint, through a few minor faults bringing it down.

When you"re comic book grading, you need to be conservative. If in doubt between a near mint minus and also a really fine, always presume it"s an extremely fine, and also then the just surprises can be good ones.

You can expect one otherwise very nice sheathe to have one corner with a crease, some spine stress marks, a little wear. However it"s a really nice spring comic.

NOTE: This is the class that many inexperienced comic publication graders think is "mint". therefore if you watch a collection explained as mint, presume it"s actually an extremely fine.

What a an extremely Fine/Near Mint (9.0 Graded) Comic publication Looks Like

Most close to mint minus comic books have just one little fault bringing lock down. Maybe a patch of wear ~ above a former cover edge, maybe one edge creased and also breaking color.

Almost anybody through no endure would speak to this comic "mint".

What a close to Mint Minus (9.2 Graded) Comic publication Looks Like

The most usual fault at near mint is shade breaking spine stress.

That, or a small, little corner crease.

Anything the breaks color is walking to prevent this book from getting to 9.4 or higher.

What a close to Mint (9.4 Graded) Comic book Looks Like

We"re right into super-picky territory here.

Sorry come say that MINT comics are really rare, and here"s why. The understanding gets really petty as soon as you"re comic book grading close to mint come gem mint comic books.

The tiniest spine stress takes you under 0.2. A fingerprint on one otherwise perfect gloss, or any kind of gloss wear on the spine, bring away it under from mint.

This yes, really doesn"t matter to you if every you want to do is sell an old collection you came into.

What a close to Mint add to (9.6 Grade) Comic publication Looks Like

Even pickier 보다 a 9.4, a 9.6 comic publication can only have one very small fault really.

The cover have to be more or much less perfect, v no division in the cover gloss. The over image is hard to make out, however there"s a little bump come the peak of the spine.

Otherwise this publication would class 9.8.

What a close to Mint/Mint (9.8 Grade) Comic book Looks Like

Call "mint" brand brand-new minus. Somebody dared to check out this when upon a lengthy ago, and also now the comic shows very minor indications of handling.

Otherwise, it"s perfect.

Mint 9.9 or Gem Mint 10.0...

Forget it! this don"t exist.

Well, okay, they perform exist, but only if a comic to be bought and stored immediately in perfect conditions, and also has never been disturbed since.

If you uncover anything this perfect, DON"T also OPEN IT! just opening the could reason spine stress.

See more: How To Transfer 8Mm Film To Dvd Yourself, 8Mm Tape Converter To Dvd

Need help With Comic book Grading?

If you have an old collection, yet can"t gain your head approximately comic book grading, climate take photos or scans and also send details to united state for a complimentary appraisal.